A slow-burning confrontation with jealousy, emotional ambiguity, and the ache of being someone’s secret, Reneé Rapp’s “Why Is She Still Here?” is for the ones who were never fully claimed, but still carry the weight of being replaced. Some heartbreaks don’t come with a goodbye.
follow our Today’s Song(s) playlist
Stream: “Why Is She Still Here?” – Reneé Rapp
Reneé Rapp’s “Why Is She Still Here?” opens with a line that doesn’t flinch: “You can tell me you don’t love her, but you should probably tell her too.”
It’s not dramatic, but it’s direct – the kind of lyric that feels like it’s been sitting in your throat for weeks, waiting to be said. Rapp doesn’t waste time setting the scene. She’s already in it: Tangled in jealousy, blurred boundaries, and the quiet realization that she’s been sharing space with someone who was never supposed to stay.
You can tell me you don’t love her
But you should probably tell her too
‘Cause I can’t keep sleeping undercover
It’s like she’s always in the room
She’s on that towel
wrapped up around my head
And that note that’s stuck to the mirror
I shouldn’t have read
No, it’s not fair
‘Cause if it’s you and I, then
Why is she still here?
Say you w-w-want me like
“Why’s she still here?”
If you w-w-want me like
Released July 18, 2025, the third single from Rapp’s upcoming sophomore album BITE ME is a stark departure from the pop-rock bravado of “Leave Me Alone” and “Mad.” This track doesn’t chase drama it sits in it. It’s slow, stripped down, and emotionally surgical. Rapp isn’t performing heartbreak. She’s documenting it.
The song opens like a raw confrontation. Built around a soft bass groove and minimal percussion, the production leaves space for Rapp’s voice to do the heavy lifting. And it does. Her delivery is restrained but cutting, like someone who’s rehearsed this conversation in their head a hundred times and finally decided to say it out loud. “She’s on that towel wrapped up around my head, and that note that’s stuck to the mirror I shouldn’t have read.” These aren’t poetic flourishes they’re evidence. Proof that someone else’s presence still lingers in the spaces Rapp was supposed to call her own.
No, I didn’t say shit when you
introduced me as your friend (Uh-huh)
And yes, that’s what it is,
but don’t you do that shit again
It’s funny ’cause it didn’t feel like
friends on the kitchen floor, no
I don’t take friends to the back of my tour bus
I’d always give when you wanted more, but
God forbid I draw any attention
to questions you never answered
Well, except for, “Who’s f*ing you better?”
You got me lowering standards
She’s still there, so tell me now
This isn’t a breakup song. It’s a song about being sidelined. About being introduced as a friend while playing the role of something much deeper. “No, I didn’t say shit when you introduced me as your friend,” she sings, and it’s not just a lyric; it’s a wound. The kind that doesn’t bleed, but bruises.
The emotional tension is mirrored in the production, handled by Alexander 23, Julian Bunetta, and Omer Fedi. There’s no crescendo, no dramatic shift, just a steady pulse of discomfort. The instrumentation is sparse: bass guitar, ambient synths, and the occasional flicker of percussion. It’s a sonic choice that mirrors the emotional restraint of the lyrics. Nothing is overdone. Everything is intentional.
Visually, the rollout leaned into noir aesthetics. Rapp teased the track with cryptic Instagram captions and followed up with moody visuals leather jacket, smokey eyeshadow, dim lighting. It’s not just a look. It’s a mood. One that says, “I’ve been quiet long enough.”
Lyrically, Rapp is at her most incisive. She doesn’t ask for clarity she demands it. “God forbid I draw any attention to questions you never answered.” It’s a line that exposes the emotional labor she’s been doing, the silence she’s been swallowing, and the dignity she’s been denied. The outro circles back to the central question, but this time it’s not rhetorical: “If I’m your girl, then why is she still here?” It’s not just a lyric. It’s a line in the sand.
Why I’m still here?
Say you w-w-want me like
“Why’s she still here?”
I need you to myself tonight
Why’s she still here?
What else more do you need?
When you got me right here
If you w-w-want me like
“Why Is She Still Here?” doesn’t try to resolve anything. It doesn’t offer closure.
It just exists for the people who’ve been made to feel like a placeholder. For the ones who’ve given too much and received half-truths in return. For the ones who’ve had to ask why someone else still occupies space that was never theirs to begin with.
It’s the kind of ache that slips into ordinary moments silent, unshakable, and suddenly heavy. The kind that reminds you that you weren’t picked, just available. And Rapp doesn’t embellish it – she sketches it plainly, letting the rawness speak for itself.
You can tell me you don’t love her
But you should probably tell her too
‘Cause I can’t keep sleeping undercover
‘Cause if I’m your girl, then why is she still here?
— —
:: stream/purchase Why Is She Still Here? here ::
:: connect with Reneé Rapp here ::
:: pre-order BITE ME here ::
— —
Stream: “Why Is She Still Here?” – Reneé Rapp
— — — —
Connect to Reneé Rapp on
Facebook, 𝕏, TikTok, Instagram
Discover new music on Atwood Magazine
© Zora Sicher
© Zora Sicher
:: Today’s Song(s) ::
follow our daily playlist on Spotify
:: Stream Reneé Rapp ::
