Melanie Martinez has never been interested in subtlety, but HADES doesn’t just push her signature theatricality further; it drags it screaming into the underworld.

Across 18 tracks and just over 70 minutes, Martinez constructs a dark-pop descent that feels less like an album and more like an immersive, allegorical experience. If her earlier work explored childhood, trauma, and transformation through a surreal lens, HADES – her fourth studio album and the first half of an ambitious dual release – abandons innocence entirely. What remains is something colder, sharper, and far more confrontational.

HADES - Melanie Martinez — HADES – Melanie Martinez

From the opening seconds of “GARBAGE,” Martinez makes it clear this is not a passive listen. Gunfire cracks through distorted instrumentation, swallowed by a roar of crowds and static noise, an overwhelming introduction that mirrors the chaos of modern life. It’s abrasive by design, evoking information overload and societal numbness. Lyrically, it’s equally unrelenting, tackling violence, religious symbolism, and state control in a way that feels deliberately disorienting. This is the sound of a world collapsing in on itself, and Martinez is both narrator and unwilling participant.

That tension, between beauty and brutality, sweetness and decay, defines HADES. The lead single “Possession” encapsulates it perfectly. On the surface, it’s melodic and almost hypnotic, but beneath that lies a chilling narrative of love curdled into control. Martinez’s vocal delivery remains soft, even delicate, which only amplifies the unease. It’s a bold statement piece, marking a clear departure from the “Cry Baby” persona and signaling that whatever innocence once defined her world has long since been buried.

Melanie Martinez’s “POSSESSION” Is a Candy-Coated Descent into HADES

:: REVIEW ::

The follow-up single “Disney Princess” continues this critique, albeit with a more satirical edge. Here, Martinez turns her focus to the commodification of women, using the familiar iconography of fairy-tale femininity as a weapon rather than a comfort. The production leans into alt-pop territory, playful but biting, while her lyrics dissect the entertainment industry as a microcosm of wider societal exploitation. It’s clever without being heavy-handed, and its catchiness only sharpens its critique.

Throughout the album, Martinez leans heavily on contrast as a storytelling tool. “WHITE BOY WITH A GUN” is deceptively relaxed, built on airy percussion and a dreamy bass line. But its understated sound only intensifies the sting of its lyrics, which take aim at misogyny with dry precision. Similarly, “THE VATICAN” blends haunting choral elements with sleek synths, creating a sonic clash that mirrors its exploration of religious hypocrisy. Lines like “Catholic, Christian, kissing Jesus, licking AR-15s” are intentionally jarring, provocations designed to unsettle rather than comfort.

There’s a meticulous attention to detail woven through HADES. On “MONOPOLY MAN,” the faint clinking of coins underscores its commentary on capitalism and control, while “CHATROOM” incorporates nostalgic AOL Messenger sounds, grounding its reflections on online bullying in a very specific digital past. These choices aren’t gimmicks; they’re extensions of Martinez’s world-building, small sonic cues that deepen the album’s immersive quality.

That sense of immersion becomes particularly striking in the album’s middle stretch. Tracks like “AVOIDANT” and “MONOLITH” strip back the chaos, offering moments of vulnerability that feel almost intrusive. “AVOIDANT” unfolds through layered harmonies before dissolving into a tinnitus-like ring, while “MONOLITH” centers around a stark piano arrangement. Here, Martinez turns inward, examining toxic relationships and emotional dependency with a rawness that contrasts sharply with the album’s more theatrical moments. It’s a necessary pause, allowing the listener to catch their breath before the descent continues.

Because it does continue, and with renewed intensity. “THE PLAGUE” erupts in a frenzy of glitchy synths and distorted textures, with faint coughing sounds woven into the mix. It’s claustrophobic and deeply unsettling, capturing both literal and metaphorical contagion. The transition into “GUTTER,” punctuated by a news clip about forced homeless encampment clearings, is one of the album’s most grounded and devastating moments. Here, Martinez drops much of the allegory, confronting systemic issues with stark clarity.

Melanie Martinez "POSSESSION" © Cho Giseok — Melanie Martinez © Cho Giseok

Elsewhere, tracks like “GRUDGES” and “WEIGHT WATCHERS” channel a more personal kind of rage. “GRUDGES” spirals through abrasive, lo-fi production, evoking a horror-game atmosphere that feels both nostalgic and newly menacing. It’s a cathartic exploration of resentment, while “WEIGHT WATCHERS” expands that anger outward, tackling societal pressures around body image with biting precision. Together, they form a thematic throughline of feminine rage, messy, justified, and ultimately liberating.

What’s most impressive about HADES is how seamlessly it balances these shifting tones. It’s an album of extremes, moving from chaos to quiet, from satire to sincerity, without ever feeling disjointed. Much of that cohesion comes from Martinez’s collaboration with producer CJ Baran, whose electronic-alt-pop framework provides a consistent backbone even as the songs themselves veer into darker, more experimental territory. The production is sleek but never sterile, allowing moments of menace to creep in at the edges.

The closing track, “THE LAST TWO PEOPLE ON EARTH,” brings everything into focus. It’s a melancholic, almost haunting finale that strips away much of the album’s earlier aggression, leaving behind something quieter but no less heavy. There’s a sense of isolation here, of longing tempered by the realization of humanity’s smallness in the grand scheme of things. It doesn’t offer resolution so much as reflection, a fitting end to an album that refuses easy answers.

Melanie Martinez 'HADES' © Cho Giseok — Melanie Martinez ‘HADES’ © Cho Giseok

HADES is not designed for casual listening. It demands engagement, patience, and a willingness to sit with discomfort.

But for those willing to meet it on its terms, it offers something rare: A fully realized artistic vision that feels both deeply personal and sharply attuned to the world around it. Martinez doesn’t chase trends or viral moments here. Instead, she trusts in atmosphere, in storytelling, in the power of unsettling imagery and layered metaphor.

If Cry Baby was about navigating a hostile world with wounded innocence, and both K-12 and Portals expanded that journey into surreal, transformative spaces, HADES is where the illusion fully fractures. It’s about confronting what lies beneath, the systems, structures, and ideologies that shape that world. This isn’t rebirth; it’s reckoning.

And in that descent, Martinez proves herself not just as a pop artist, but as a meticulous world-builder, unafraid to evolve her mythology into something darker, stranger, and far more unsettling.

— —